NOSSO COMPROMISSO

Realizar projetos de organização patrimonial, proporcionando aos clientes a satisfação diante das expectativas com o controle dos bens de ativo imobilizado, atendendo normas técnicas e a legislação vigente!

Realizar projetos de organização patrimonial, proporcionando aos clientes a satisfação diante das expectativas com o controle dos bens de ativo imobilizado, atendendo normas técnicas e a legislação vigente!

solicite um orçamento

Clique no botão acima e entre em contato conosco! Nossa equipe está pronta para lhe atender.

Asset Recoverability: Transparency, IAS 36 and Reliability of Financial Statements in Multinational Groups

Asset Recoverability: Transparency, IAS 36 and Reliability of Financial Statements in Multinational Groups

Asset Recoverability: Transparency, IAS 36 and Reliability of Financial Statements in Multinational Groups

For a multinational company, the quality of financial information does not end with the financial statements of a local subsidiary.

Figures produced in Brazil may feed into the consolidated financial statements of groups headquartered in the United States, Europe, Asia, or any other region of the world. An asset recorded in a Brazilian operation may therefore have an impact on the group’s equity, profit or loss, financial indicators, and strategic decisions at a global level.

In this environment, one essential question arises:

Do the assets recorded in the accounting records represent amounts that are actually recoverable, or is the company consolidating figures that no longer reflect the economic reality of its operations?

This question is directly related to the Impairment Test, or Asset Recoverability Test.

In Brazil, this matter is governed by CPC 01 – Impairment of Assets, which is correlated with IAS 36 – Impairment of Assets. The fundamental principle of IAS 36 is to prevent an asset from being carried in the financial statements at an amount higher than the amount that can be recovered through use or sale.

For multinational groups, impairment should therefore not be treated merely as a local accounting matter.

It is part of global financial governance.

The multinational challenge: turning local operations into globally reliable information

Consider a multinational group headquartered in Germany, the United States, or France, with industrial operations in Brazil.

The Brazilian subsidiary may own plants, distribution centers, industrial equipment, production lines, facilities, vehicles, and other significant assets.

These assets are recorded locally, but their carrying amounts may ultimately be incorporated into the consolidated financial statements of the group.

Headquarters expects those figures to be reliable.

The group auditor expects the same.

Investors, banks, and other stakeholders use those financial statements to make decisions.

This means that an asset inconsistency at a subsidiary level may cease to be merely a local issue.

It may become a matter of consolidated reporting quality.

This is precisely why multinational companies maintain corporate accounting policies, closing procedures, internal controls, audit calendars, and financial reporting validation processes.

Asset recoverability needs to be part of that control environment.

CPC 01 and IAS 36: a common language for asset recoverability

Brazil’s convergence process with international accounting standards has significantly aligned local accounting practices with IFRS.

In the specific case of impairment, CPC 01 is directly correlated with IAS 36.

For a multinational company that applies IFRS in its consolidation process, this alignment is highly relevant.

The underlying principle is clear:

No asset should remain recognized at an amount higher than its recoverable amount.

Recoverable amount is determined as the higher of:

value in use

and

fair value less costs of disposal.

If the carrying amount exceeds the recoverable amount, an impairment loss exists and must be recognized in accordance with the applicable accounting requirements.

The concept is relatively straightforward.

Its application, however, may be quite complex.

The first risk lies in the asset base itself

Before building financial models, estimating future cash flows, or discussing discount rates, there is an earlier and more fundamental question:

Does the company know exactly which assets it owns and controls?

In asset management projects involving companies with many years of operations, situations such as the following may be found:

  • assets recorded in the accounting records that no longer physically exist;
  • decommissioned machines that remain in the fixed asset register;
  • equipment that has been replaced without the related accounting records being updated;
  • assets transferred between plants without corresponding updates to location records;
  • assets without individual identification;
  • generic descriptions that make traceability difficult;
  • differences between physical location and accounting location;
  • obsolete equipment still recorded at material carrying amounts;
  • assets grouped for accounting purposes in a way that makes individual analysis difficult.

These inconsistencies create significant issues for any impairment process.

There can be no robust asset valuation when the company does not have a reliable understanding of its own asset base.

For this reason, depending on the circumstances, a technically consistent process may first require:

physical inventory, physical-to-accounting reconciliation, asset register cleansing, and review of the asset structure.

Only after this foundation has been strengthened can the subsequent stages be performed with a higher level of reliability.

It is not merely an accounting requirement: it is a governance issue

For the financial executive of a multinational company, the discussion should go beyond formal compliance with accounting standards.

Impairment should be viewed from the perspective of corporate governance, risk management, and financial information quality.

Consider an industrial production line with a carrying amount of BRL 30 million.

The equipment is still physically installed.

However, utilization has fallen significantly.

Demand for the product has declined.

Part of the technology has become obsolete.

Expected cash generation has weakened.

In such a case, simply confirming that the equipment still exists does not demonstrate that its full carrying amount remains recoverable.

Its economic capacity needs to be assessed.

This distinction between physical existence and economic recoverability is precisely what makes impairment particularly relevant.

Value in use: assessing economic generation capacity

Value in use seeks to measure the present value of the future cash flows expected to arise from the continuing use of the asset or, when applicable, from the corresponding Cash-Generating Unit, or CGU.

IAS 36 recognizes that certain individual assets do not generate cash inflows independently. In these situations, the assessment may need to be performed at the level of the smallest cash-generating unit capable of generating largely independent cash inflows.

For multinational groups, this analysis may involve:

  • financial projections approved by management;
  • growth assumptions;
  • production volumes;
  • operating margins;
  • market expectations;
  • cost structures;
  • discount rates;
  • remaining economic lives of assets;
  • operating capacity;
  • macroeconomic assumptions.

The more material the asset or CGU, the greater the need for proper documentation and support for the assumptions applied.

Fair value less costs of disposal

The second reference used to determine recoverable amount relates to the value that could be obtained from the sale of the asset or the related unit, less the costs of disposal.

In certain industrial sectors, this analysis requires highly specific technical knowledge.

One machine may have significant value to the company but a very limited secondary market.

Another asset may have strong international liquidity.

Depending on the asset, factors such as age, manufacturer, model, capacity, maintenance history, geographic location, and dismantling costs may significantly affect its market value.

Accordingly, it is not enough to apply a generic percentage to historical cost.

The valuation should take into account the actual characteristics of the asset and the prevailing market conditions.

The risk of reporting overstated assets

One of the main purposes of impairment is to prevent financial statements from presenting assets above their recoverable amounts.

When this happens, several financial indicators may be affected, including:

  • total assets;
  • shareholders’ equity;
  • profit or loss for the period;
  • return on assets;
  • profitability indicators;
  • certain financial covenants;
  • investment analyses.

For a multinational company, the consequences may go beyond the local subsidiary.

Depending on materiality, a local misstatement may affect the consolidated financial statements of the group.

For this reason, impairment should also be understood as part of the integrity of the financial consolidation process.

Local audit and group audit

In multinational groups, there is often an additional layer of complexity.

The subsidiary may be subject to a local independent audit while also being included within the scope of the group audit.

This can increase the need for traceability and support of the information presented.

Auditors may request documentation relating to:

  • impairment indicators;
  • assumptions applied;
  • financial projections;
  • determination of CGUs;
  • discount rates;
  • technical valuations;
  • calculation support;
  • market evidence;
  • approval of assumptions by management.

In this context, an impairment report should not function merely as a formal document filed to satisfy a request.

It should function as technical evidence.

When should impairment testing be performed?

IAS 36 requires an entity, at the end of each reporting period, to assess whether there is any indication that an asset may be impaired. When such an indication exists, the entity is required to estimate the recoverable amount.

Certain categories of assets are subject to specific annual testing requirements, such as goodwill acquired in a business combination, intangible assets with indefinite useful lives, and certain intangible assets not yet available for use.

For other assets, the existence of impairment indicators is a key factor.

Those indicators may arise from both external and internal sources.

Examples may include significant market changes, technological developments, declining demand, operating performance below expectations, idle capacity, closure of facilities, or restructuring decisions.

This is why impairment should not be viewed simply as an automatic calculation performed at year-end.

It involves judgment, risk identification, and documentation.

Multinational companies must reconcile two realities

A foreign company operating in Brazil generally needs to deal with two environments.

On one side, there are local accounting requirements and practices.

On the other, there are the accounting policies and criteria defined by headquarters.

The challenge is to ensure that locally produced information is sufficiently robust to support corporate reporting.

It is common for headquarters to send reporting packages, closing instructions, and impairment policies.

However, local execution depends on a proper understanding of the assets located in Brazil.

This is precisely where local finance, controlling, accounting, engineering, and asset management teams need to work in an integrated manner.

Acquisitions and restructurings make asset recoverability even more relevant

The issue becomes even more important when a company is involved in acquisitions, mergers, corporate reorganizations, or strategic portfolio reviews.

An acquired company may have hundreds of millions of reais recorded in property, plant and equipment.

Before those figures can be considered representative of economic reality, investors and management need to understand:

  • which assets actually exist;
  • their physical condition;
  • how they are being used;
  • which assets continue to generate economic benefits;
  • which assets are technologically obsolete;
  • and what their recoverability capacity is.

An acquisition transforms asset information into information directly related to capital allocation.

In this context, the quality of the asset base is no longer merely an operational issue.

It becomes part of the strategic investment analysis.

Financial transparency is a global responsibility

CFOs, controllers, finance directors, and professionals responsible for financial reporting need to understand one fundamental point:

Property, plant and equipment cannot be managed merely as an accounting register.

It represents invested capital.

It represents operating capacity.

It represents resources that must generate economic benefits.

And the values reported need to be supportable.

For a multinational group, this responsibility is even greater because figures from different countries are consolidated into a single set of financial statements.

The purpose of impairment testing is not simply to identify losses.

Its purpose is to ensure that the carrying amount remains supported by the economic capacity of the asset or cash-generating unit.

The question that should reach headquarters

Perhaps one of the most important questions a regional CFO can ask before approving a reporting package is:

Can we demonstrate, on a technically supportable basis, that the carrying amounts of our assets are recoverable?

If the answer is based only on the fact that the equipment remains in operation or that there is no intention to sell it, the analysis may be insufficient.

The economic fundamentals need to be considered.

The asset needs to be understood.

Its utilization needs to be assessed.

Its cash-generating capacity needs to be evaluated.

And the assumptions used need to be properly documented.

In the international corporate environment, transparency does not simply mean disclosing figures.

It means being able to explain and technically support every material figure reported.

This is one of the core objectives of IAS 36 and CPC 01.

For multinational companies operating in Brazil, as well as Brazilian companies that are part of international groups, asset recoverability should therefore remain part of a permanent agenda involving governance, accounting compliance, asset management, and financial reporting quality.

 

For a multinational company, the quality of financial information does not end with the financial statements of a local subsidiary. Figures produced in Brazil may feed into the consolidated financial statements of groups headquartered in the United States, Europe, Asia, or any other region of the world. An asset recorded in a Brazilian operation may therefore have an impact on the group’s equity, profit or loss, financial indicators, and strategic decisions at a global level. In this environment, one essential question arises:
Rolar para cima